There has been somewhat of a long-standing debate between which snowmobile engine is better since the 4-stroke engine first became available. I don’t think one is better than the other. It just depends on your riding style and preferences.
I’ve been an avid snowmobiler for most of my life, and I have decades of experience riding all over North America. I have used many different 2-stroke and 4-stroke sleds over the years, and I know through first-hand experience their main differences.
This post will touch on the differences between 2-stroke and 4-stroke snowmobiles to give you a better understanding of why you might want to use one over the other. I’ll touch on the advantages of each engine to help you know more about them.
Let’s dive in.
Table of Contents
- The Big Debate
- Engine Style Defined
- 2 Stroke vs 4 Stroke Snowmobile
- Final Thoughts
The Big Debate
If you ask ten different snowmobilers, they will all probably have a different recommendation on whether to use a 2-stroke or 4-stroke snowmobile.
The truth is there isn’t one right or wrong answer here, and both styles of engines work well in different situations.
I have had good experiences with both 2-stroke and 4-stroke sleds and still use 2-stroke machines more often. This is just my personal preference and what sleds I have owned over the years.
Engine Style Defined
Looking at things from a clear perspective, it’s good to know what defines a 2-stroke and 4-stroke engine, whether that is looking at a snowmobile or any other machine.
A 2-stroke engine generates power on every other stroke of the pistons in the engine, while a 4-stroke engine generates power on every fourth stroke. That may not mean much unless you understand how an engine works in the first place, but they are two completely different designs.
Rather than get into the specifics of how these engines work, I think it’s a better idea for this article to explain how the differences affect how a snowmobile operates in the snow.
2 Stroke vs 4 Stroke Snowmobile
I’ll break down all of the main differences between 2-stroke and 4-stroke snowmobiles here to give you a better understanding of both.
|Design||Simpler/More heat||More complex/More parts|
|Cost||Less expensive||More expensive|
|Performance||More power||Better compression ratios|
|Emissions||Higher emissions||Lower emissions|
2-stroke snowmobiles have been around for longer because they have a simpler, more basic design. 4-stroke sleds are more complex and require more complicated engineering, so they have only become more available in recent years.
The design of a 2-stroke engine also generates more heat, which means that they need a better cooling system than a 4-stroke engine. But a 4-stroke engine has more parts, which can cause more weight overall for the sled.
Another big difference is that 2-stroke engines require a mix of gas and oil. So these types of engines burn up oil in the fuel, and you’ll end up using more oil in the long run. 4-stroke engines can reuse oil, so you don’t burn as much during regular operation.
2-stroke snowmobiles are generally cheaper than 4-stroke sleds because a 2-stroke engine is cheaper to build. But a 4-stroke engine will last a lot longer in total operating life, so upfront cost should be compared against lifetime use.
There are more moving parts in a 4-stroke engine, which typically means that there is more need for potential maintenance. But again, these engines will last longer than 2-stroke, so they can be a better or similar value in the long run.
Most riders will tell you that 2-stroke snowmobiles are more powerful than a 4-stroke. But a 4-stroke will give you better compression ratios. These slight differences in performance will probably only be noticed by experienced riders.
2-stroke snowmobiles are lighter because the engine doesn’t have as many components, making them easier to maneuver in tight situations than larger 4-stroke models.
This weight consideration also means that 2-stroke sleds have a lower center of gravity, giving you better handling when making fast manuevers.
2-stroke engines are not as environmentally friendly as 4-stroke engines. 2-stroke engines don’t actually create complete combustion, meaning that not all of the fuel is burned up during each engine cycle. This causes excess fuel to be ejected into the atmosphere (emissions).
4-stroke engines have near-complete combustion, which results in fewer emissions and better performance for the environment. These engines are more modern and can therefore be more fuel-efficient as well.
Another consideration you might want to know about when choosing between these snowmobiles is that 2-stroke engines are usually louder than 4-stroke models. If you want a more peaceful experience or don’t want to disturb nature and animals, keep this in mind.
And 2-stroke engines will typically be able to stay in operation when they get flipped upside or operate at high ride angles. If a 4-stroke engine remains upside down for a long time, the oil flow can get messed up, leading to engine damage.
This is something to keep in mind if you like to ride on really steep terrain or tend to bale off your sled often. 2-stroke engines are a little less particular, and you can beat them up without worry. 4-strokes shouldn’t be left upside for an extended amount of time.
How to Tell the Difference between 4 Stroke and 2 Stroke?
One of the easiest ways to tell the difference between a 4-stroke and 2-stroke engine is to listen to it while it is running. A 4-stroke engine will have a smoother sound that has a constant hum. A 2-stroke engine will be a little louder with sporadic popping sounds.
2 Stroke vs 4 Stroke: Which One is Better for Trail Riding?
4-stroke engines can be better for long-distance trail riding because of the liquid-cooled engines and better gas mileage. But both of these engines can work well for trail riding, it just depends on your needs and preferences.
Do 4 Strokes Last Longer than 2 Strokes?
This is a widely circulated statement, but it really doesn’t hold up. 4-stroke and 2-stroke machines can both be very dependable and last a long time. This is especially true with newer machines, but you might see some more lifetime mileage from a 4-stroke.
Will 2-strokes Make a Comeback?
I don’t think that 2-strokes will make a big comeback. But I also don’t believe that they will become obsolete any time soon. They are still pretty popular with hardcore riders and have some advantages that keep them marketable.
As you can see, there are quite a few differences between 2-stroke and 4-stroke snowmobiles. A lot of this won’t mean much to the casual rider, but it’s good information to know and understand if you are looking at buying a new machine.
That said, I don’t really have a particular recommendation as to which style engine is best. Take all of the information here to heart, and try to decide based on your riding style and preferences. There are plenty of good options in both types available.About Chaz Wyland